Author Topic: DIY door lining to reduce wind noise: who's interested?  (Read 215353 times)

Offline corgan

  • Max Torque (4400 rpm)
  • ****
  • Posts: 2,246
DIY door lining to reduce wind noise: who's interested?
« on: November 30, 2006, 10:06:56 PM »
Just to share with all, I have DIYed a second door lining to help reduce the wind noise. As you all would have noticed, once our rides hit 80km/h and above, you can start to hear wind noise coming in.  :out: But with this DIYed door lining, the noise only becomes noticeable at about 100km/h and the volume of it is definitely 30-50% lower than before. :thumbsup: Best of all, this DIY lining will not cost more than $15.   :devil2: After doing the lining, I found the door harder to close because of the extra padding but its slowly getting seasoned and getting easier to close now.

here are some pics to show you what i mean.

before:



after:



Thinking of organising a mini DIY session to do this and if you are interested, pls add your name to the list below. Session will most likely be this sunday or next sunday.

1.
2.
3.
4.
« Last Edit: December 01, 2006, 02:49:02 AM by corgan »


My ICE journey so far - Pioneer P80RS - Morel Supremo Piccolo Tweeters - Morel Elate Midbass - Butler 475 - OZ vector 3 12" sub - Alpine MRP650 - MIT EXp2 Interconnects

vince69

  • Guest
Re: DIY door lining to reduce wind noise
« Reply #1 on: November 30, 2006, 11:12:58 PM »
may I ask, what type of material you are using for this? where to buy them? and any special tool needed?
Thanks

Nick Lee

  • Guest
Re: DIY door lining to reduce wind noise
« Reply #2 on: November 30, 2006, 11:26:04 PM »
Thinking of organising a mini DIY session to do this and if you are interested, pls add your name to the list below. Session will most likely be this sunday or next sunday.

1.Nick Lee
2.
3.
4.

Offline corgan

  • Max Torque (4400 rpm)
  • ****
  • Posts: 2,246
Re: DIY door lining to reduce wind noise
« Reply #3 on: November 30, 2006, 11:28:19 PM »
may I ask, what type of material you are using for this? where to buy them? and any special tool needed?
Thanks

its a foam-like material. exact material and where to get it i got no idea also. sorry abt that. :smile: no special tool needed, just a pair of scissors to cut the lining once u stick it onto the door frame. the lining has dbl sided tape behind it for u to attached. less than 15mins can do up 1 whole car le.  ;)


My ICE journey so far - Pioneer P80RS - Morel Supremo Piccolo Tweeters - Morel Elate Midbass - Butler 475 - OZ vector 3 12" sub - Alpine MRP650 - MIT EXp2 Interconnects

vince69

  • Guest
Re: DIY door lining to reduce wind noise
« Reply #4 on: November 30, 2006, 11:32:13 PM »
its a foam-like material. exact material and where to get it i got no idea also. sorry abt that. :smile: no special tool needed, just a pair of scissors to cut the lining once u stick it onto the door frame. the lining has dbl sided tape behind it for u to attached. less than 15mins can do up 1 whole car le.  ;)

ok, thanks... then how/where to get the materials for the DIY? :confused1:

Offline corgan

  • Max Torque (4400 rpm)
  • ****
  • Posts: 2,246
Re: DIY door lining to reduce wind noise
« Reply #5 on: November 30, 2006, 11:58:13 PM »
ok, thanks... then how/where to get the materials for the DIY? :confused1:

just indicate your interest in the list i made. Once i got enough people interested, I'll get my friend to help me get the material. Its his lobang afterall. ;)


My ICE journey so far - Pioneer P80RS - Morel Supremo Piccolo Tweeters - Morel Elate Midbass - Butler 475 - OZ vector 3 12" sub - Alpine MRP650 - MIT EXp2 Interconnects

Offline corgan

  • Max Torque (4400 rpm)
  • ****
  • Posts: 2,246
Re: DIY door lining to reduce wind noise
« Reply #6 on: December 01, 2006, 12:04:35 AM »
anyway, will be going down to the meetup at YD on friday night. So if you're nearby and want to take a look at the lining. Just pop by ya?  :D


My ICE journey so far - Pioneer P80RS - Morel Supremo Piccolo Tweeters - Morel Elate Midbass - Butler 475 - OZ vector 3 12" sub - Alpine MRP650 - MIT EXp2 Interconnects

vince69

  • Guest
Re: DIY door lining to reduce wind noise
« Reply #7 on: December 01, 2006, 12:10:19 AM »
anyway, will be going down to the meetup at YD on friday night. So if you're nearby and want to take a look at the lining. Just pop by ya?  :D

ok, already put my name on the YD list, but most likely will be late though.. :smile:

Offline corgan

  • Max Torque (4400 rpm)
  • ****
  • Posts: 2,246
Re: DIY door lining to reduce wind noise
« Reply #8 on: December 01, 2006, 12:15:13 AM »
People interested in the DIY door lining.

1.Nick Lee
2.
3.
4.


My ICE journey so far - Pioneer P80RS - Morel Supremo Piccolo Tweeters - Morel Elate Midbass - Butler 475 - OZ vector 3 12" sub - Alpine MRP650 - MIT EXp2 Interconnects

Offline best_ctzn

  • Mid Zone (3000 rpm)
  • ***
  • Posts: 469
  • Life has been so kind to me!!!
Re: DIY door lining to reduce wind noise: who's interested?
« Reply #9 on: December 01, 2006, 08:02:18 AM »
Hi to all. Few months ago I did ponder the merit of this DIY idea. The insulating material can be purchased from HomeFix easily at $10/tube. There are different diameter type and length, most brown and black. So must do rough measurement of our door circumference to decide on length to get.

But in the end I rejected it because I found out that our original Latio door seals are already of double-insulation type. If you look closely there are 2 circles of the seals around each door. That is why our car has outstanding noise insulation, compare to other cars like Sunny, Lancer, etc. The more you check, the more you will appreciate our Latio quality. My opinion was that adding additional layer will not increase SP by much lah.

And adding the DIY seal will definitely make the door harder to close, which I am not sure is something I want to endure everyday. Not to pour cold water lah, just share my 2cts worth of opinion.

And while at HomeFix, maybe you want to check out a 3M product that look like a spray can costing $15 (?). You just spray its contents to the wheel arches and the foam will harden very quickly, forming a hard resin like material to supposedly increase the noise insulation property at these corners (much like that done at SP shops). My friend told me a can is good enough for more than 2 wheel archs and it feel quite heavy. But personally I feel stock is good enough but those who are interested could try out and give FR lah.

Offline corgan

  • Max Torque (4400 rpm)
  • ****
  • Posts: 2,246
Re: DIY door lining to reduce wind noise: who's interested?
« Reply #10 on: December 01, 2006, 10:23:01 AM »
nah. no such thing as pour cold water. You're free to give your views bro. At least I know where my friend gets them.  :D  Homefix?

As for the sound insulation of our latios, I have to admit the quality is a lot better when compared to other cars in the same class but wind noise is a bother to me. Was trying to find a way to reduce the wind noise and happened to chanced upon this DIY lining at another forum. For the price and effort, I believe its a good deal especially if you drive spiritedly and always go fast on expressways.  :devil2: Hence I still stand by my pt that wind noise has been reduced 30-50% overall. Anyway, I'm going to YD today so that other bros and sis there can take a look at it and decide for themselves. Maybe can take them for testdrive also :D



My ICE journey so far - Pioneer P80RS - Morel Supremo Piccolo Tweeters - Morel Elate Midbass - Butler 475 - OZ vector 3 12" sub - Alpine MRP650 - MIT EXp2 Interconnects

Offline infinityx

  • Low End (2000 rpm)
  • **
  • Posts: 401
  • To overcome fear, One must be the fear!
Re: DIY door lining to reduce wind noise: who's interested?
« Reply #11 on: December 01, 2006, 11:43:02 AM »
nah. no such thing as pour cold water. You're free to give your views bro. At least I know where my friend gets them.  :D  Homefix?

As for the sound insulation of our latios, I have to admit the quality is a lot better when compared to other cars in the same class but wind noise is a bother to me. Was trying to find a way to reduce the wind noise and happened to chanced upon this DIY lining at another forum. For the price and effort, I believe its a good deal especially if you drive spiritedly and always go fast on expressways.  :devil2: Hence I still stand by my pt that wind noise has been reduced 30-50% overall. Anyway, I'm going to YD today so that other bros and sis there can take a look at it and decide for themselves. Maybe can take them for testdrive also :D



Hi Jon

Way to go bro, I like your ideal of this DIY!  :thumbsup:

Tonight I need to attend and help out a wake at AMK so might not able to drop by YD. That's why did not put my name in the newbie gathering. :crying:

If I can manage to squeezeeeee some time to drop by at YD, I'll definitely like to check out your door lining.
Cheers!

Offline best_ctzn

  • Mid Zone (3000 rpm)
  • ***
  • Posts: 469
  • Life has been so kind to me!!!
Re: DIY door lining to reduce wind noise: who's interested?
« Reply #12 on: December 01, 2006, 01:22:37 PM »
nah. no such thing as pour cold water. You're free to give your views bro. At least I know where my friend gets them.  :D  Homefix?

As for the sound insulation of our latios, I have to admit the quality is a lot better when compared to other cars in the same class but wind noise is a bother to me. Was trying to find a way to reduce the wind noise and happened to chanced upon this DIY lining at another forum. For the price and effort, I believe its a good deal especially if you drive spiritedly and always go fast on expressways.  :devil2: Hence I still stand by my pt that wind noise has been reduced 30-50% overall. Anyway, I'm going to YD today so that other bros and sis there can take a look at it and decide for themselves. Maybe can take them for testdrive also :D



Hi, bro. I like ur reply.  :thumbsup:

We need ppl with positive attitude. There is definitely no right or wrong opinion. What I did was only to highlight my reservations. We all appreciate ur effort in taking pictures and sharing ur enthusiasm. It is good that you are letting other ppl try out the improvement. Those who want to try out should take note of the visor factor, and also whether they could accept the increased difficulty in closing the doors.

You can definitely get the insulation tubes at Thomson Plaza Homefix store.  But I suppose other DIY shop could have stock too. Take note there are those tubes with solid core, those without single hollow center, and those with double hollow center, and different thickess and width (much like aluminium window grill). The gap between the 2 insulation seals on our doors are a bit narrow, so must take care when buying. But safest is to get back the same design that you are using right now, as it is already available for 'audition'.

Cheers and enjoy ur DIY.








vince69

  • Guest
Re: DIY door lining to reduce wind noise: who's interested?
« Reply #13 on: December 01, 2006, 03:25:40 PM »
errr ... OOT a bit, those going YD tonight, please refer to the outing thread, think the location changed to AMK Ave 6 Macdonald (opp AMK Central Library) ... don't later go YD, cannot find anyone there hoh... ::)

http://www.thelatioclub.org/tlcforums/index.php?topic=1635.msg21684#new

Offline corgan

  • Max Torque (4400 rpm)
  • ****
  • Posts: 2,246
Re: DIY door lining to reduce wind noise: who's interested?
« Reply #14 on: December 01, 2006, 07:49:34 PM »
Hi, bro. I like ur reply.  :thumbsup:

We need ppl with positive attitude. There is definitely no right or wrong opinion. What I did was only to highlight my reservations. We all appreciate ur effort in taking pictures and sharing ur enthusiasm. It is good that you are letting other ppl try out the improvement. Those who want to try out should take note of the visor factor, and also whether they could accept the increased difficulty in closing the doors.

You can definitely get the insulation tubes at Thomson Plaza Homefix store.  But I suppose other DIY shop could have stock too. Take note there are those tubes with solid core, those without single hollow center, and those with double hollow center, and different thickess and width (much like aluminium window grill). The gap between the 2 insulation seals on our doors are a bit narrow, so must take care when buying. But safest is to get back the same design that you are using right now, as it is already available for 'audition'.

Cheers and enjoy ur DIY.


No problem bro.  :thumbsup:


My ICE journey so far - Pioneer P80RS - Morel Supremo Piccolo Tweeters - Morel Elate Midbass - Butler 475 - OZ vector 3 12" sub - Alpine MRP650 - MIT EXp2 Interconnects

Offline corgan

  • Max Torque (4400 rpm)
  • ****
  • Posts: 2,246
Re: DIY door lining to reduce wind noise: who's interested?
« Reply #15 on: December 01, 2006, 07:50:10 PM »
Just to share with all, I have DIYed a second door lining to help reduce the wind noise. As you all would have noticed, once our rides hit 80km/h and above, you can start to hear wind noise coming in.   But with this DIYed door lining, the noise only becomes noticeable at about 100km/h and the volume of it is definitely 30-50% lower than before.  Best of all, this DIY lining will not cost more than $15.    After doing the lining, I found the door harder to close because of the extra padding but its slowly getting seasoned and getting easier to close now.

here are some pics to show you what i mean.

before:






after:




Thinking of organising a mini DIY session to do this and if you are interested, pls add your name to the list below. Session will most likely be this sunday or next sunday.
1. Nick Lee
2.
3.
4.
« Last Edit: December 01, 2006, 07:53:46 PM by corgan »


My ICE journey so far - Pioneer P80RS - Morel Supremo Piccolo Tweeters - Morel Elate Midbass - Butler 475 - OZ vector 3 12" sub - Alpine MRP650 - MIT EXp2 Interconnects

Offline blackspotGG

  • Low End (2000 rpm)
  • **
  • Posts: 291
Re: DIY door lining to reduce wind noise: who's interested?
« Reply #16 on: December 02, 2006, 01:32:26 AM »
Thinking of organising a mini DIY session to do this and if you are interested, pls add your name to the list below. Session will most likely be this sunday or next sunday.
1. Nick Lee
2. BlackspotGG (Hopefully it would be the price as mentioned during the meetup at AMK)  ;D
3.
4.

Offline blackspotGG

  • Low End (2000 rpm)
  • **
  • Posts: 291
Re: DIY door lining to reduce wind noise: who's interested?
« Reply #17 on: December 02, 2006, 01:36:56 AM »
My friend (driving a honda civic FD, the new one) installed a similar sound proofing strip/door lining on his car. Think if I'm not wrong its from 3M. The material is flat and quite hard. Found it quite hard to close the doors after installation. Damage = $40.

Seen corgan's door lining last evening and its quite different from what my fren had. Its round and soft, similiar to the existing door linings we have on our car. Most important of all, damage is less than half of the 3M one..... Decided to give it a try. IF its not good, can simply just throw it away without much heartache... :bleh: :bleh: :bleh:

Offline best_ctzn

  • Mid Zone (3000 rpm)
  • ***
  • Posts: 469
  • Life has been so kind to me!!!
Re: DIY door lining to reduce wind noise: who's interested?
« Reply #18 on: December 02, 2006, 06:44:05 PM »
My friend (driving a honda civic FD, the new one) installed a similar sound proofing strip/door lining on his car. Think if I'm not wrong its from 3M. The material is flat and quite hard. Found it quite hard to close the doors after installation. Damage = $40.

Seen corgan's door lining last evening and its quite different from what my fren had. Its round and soft, similiar to the existing door linings we have on our car. Most important of all, damage is less than half of the 3M one..... Decided to give it a try. IF its not good, can simply just throw it away without much heartache... :bleh: :bleh: :bleh:

Sorry to kp abit. Ur friend civic FD is the cost for 2 doors or all 4 doors?

I believe Corgan cost of $15 only for 2 doors. Correct me if I am wrong. The few designs I saw fr Homefix are from 3M and each about 2m (depend on width and shape) cost about $10. Those small width type should be longer for same cost.  1 tube should be enough for 1 door. And if you got lobang for no brand but really big drums type, should be even cheaper.

I believe if you could get one type that is thin and narrow enough with the appropriate softness, it will be possible to reduce wind noise and yet not increase the difficulty in closing doors. That takes some effort though.



Offline blackspotGG

  • Low End (2000 rpm)
  • **
  • Posts: 291
Re: DIY door lining to reduce wind noise: who's interested?
« Reply #19 on: December 02, 2006, 11:47:00 PM »
Sorry to kp abit. Ur friend civic FD is the cost for 2 doors or all 4 doors?

I believe Corgan cost of $15 only for 2 doors. Correct me if I am wrong. The few designs I saw fr Homefix are from 3M and each about 2m (depend on width and shape) cost about $10. Those small width type should be longer for same cost.  1 tube should be enough for 1 door. And if you got lobang for no brand but really big drums type, should be even cheaper.

I believe if you could get one type that is thin and narrow enough with the appropriate softness, it will be possible to reduce wind noise and yet not increase the difficulty in closing doors. That takes some effort though.




$40 for all 4 doors for my fren's door rubber lining. He said the material from taiwan...

What I understand from Corgan is less than $15 for all 4 doors (Corgan: please correct me if I misinterpret it...). "Thin and narrow enough with the appropriate softness", the door rubber lining on Corgan's car fit exactly your description (in my personal point of view). Its quite easy to close Corgan's door as compared to my fren's FD. My fren's car I have to slam three times then can close....

When I saw the rubber door lining on Corgan's car, i was thinking to myself "Mai Tu Liao!". That's why once I reached home last night I added myself to the list...  ;D